Add Row 
Add 
The Decline of the Fixer-Upper Market
Once a beacon of hope for first-time buyers seeking affordable entries into homeownership, the allure of the fixer-upper is fading. A recent Zillow analysis reveals a notable trend where buyers are increasingly favoring remodeled homes over properties in need of renovations. In 2024, buyers are willing to pay about 3.7% more than expected for a home that has been remodeled, translating to an additional $13,194 on an average U.S. home. This is the highest premium of all 359 listing keywords analyzed by Zillow, suggesting a transformative shift in buyer priorities.
Why Buyers Prefer Remodeled Homes
The statistics tell a compelling story. Remodeled listings on Zillow are not only garnering attention but are receiving 26% more daily saves and are shared 30% more often compared to similar homes that haven’t been updated. This increased interest indicates a growing buyer seriousness, showing that many are eager to proceed with these listings. Gone are the days when fixer-uppers were marketed based on their potential. Today, it appears that the allure of a beautifully updated space outweighs the perceived value of taking on renovations.
Shifting Buyer Expectations
Notably, the past few years have seen a significant pivot in buyer expectations. A decade ago, words like "fixer," "TLC," or "good bones" often contributed positively to a home's appeal. However, that sentiment has changed, especially in the wake of the pandemic, as buyers opt for homes that are ready to move into. As Amanda Pendleton, Zillow's home trends expert states, potential homeowners grappling with tighter budgets are less inclined to invest time and money into significant renovations. Instead, they prefer the option of spreading the cost of a remodeled home across a 30-year mortgage rather than setting aside cash for immediate repairs.
The Economics Behind Fixer-Uppers
With current market dynamics, fixer-uppers now represent a bargain that is becoming less accessible. Zillow's research found that properties labeled as "fixer-upper" sell for an average of 7.3% less than their remodeled counterparts, marking the largest discount seen in three years. Homes that require work typically sell for approximately 8% less than expected, a figure that amounts to more than $28,000 savings on a typical U.S. home. Nevertheless, with rising renovation costs fueled by inflation, the affordability advantage of fixer-uppers may not offer the financial relief many buyers expect.
A Cultural Shift in Homeownership
The rise of the fixer-upper culture in the mid-2010s coincided with home price recoveries from the Great Recession. Many millennials gravitated toward affordable properties to join the housing market, often inspired by DIY shows showcasing stunning renovations. However, as home prices soared, this demographic's willingness to shoulder additional renovation costs has diminished.
The Future of Home Sales
As home values normalized, Zillow predicted a modest appreciation of 2.9% in 2025, a stark contrast to the rapid rises previously experienced. In fact, about 28% of current Zillow listings now describe homes as “renovated,” likely influenced by a renovation boom initiated by remote working conditions and expanded equity. With eager buyers seeking move-in-ready homes, sellers must adjust their expectations, underscoring that simply undergoing a massive renovation no longer guarantees a rapid return on investment.
Conclusion: A Call for Buyers to Adapt
If you're in the market for a home, it's essential to adapt to these dynamic trends. Consider the advantages of skipping renovations altogether and opting for remodeled homes that promise immediate comfort and less hassle. With the new landscape of home buying shifting towards genuinely remodeled properties, make informed decisions that align with current market realities.
Write A Comment